My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Podcast

Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.

160 - Cynthia & Barry
Karen and Georgia cover the story of Eddie Aikau and the Sleepwalking Murderer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 109
This week’s hometowns include a scuba-themed funeral and a shower-based sex cult....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

159 - Live at the Lyric in Baltimore
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Carolyn Wasilewski and the Baltimore Plot....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 108
This week’s hometowns include a dispatcher rescue and a prison ‘found in walls’ story....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

158 - Burn Day
Karen and Georgia cover the 3 Billboards murder of Kathy Page and the San Ysidro McDonald's massacre....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 107
This week’s hometowns include a suspicious dad and a mummy....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


The Live TNT’s I Am The Night Special
Karen and Georgia cover the Black Dahlia Murder in a special presentation with TNT’s I Am The Night....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

157 - Live at the Civic Theatre in San Diego
Karen and Georgia cover the Torrey Pines Beach Murders and the Rose Petal Murder....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 106
This week’s hometowns include a SWAT team invasion and a crime scene photographer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


156 - Mr. Cool & Nice - The Conan O'Brien Episode
Karen and Georgia sit down with Conan O'Brien to discuss his obsession with true crime....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 105
This week’s hometowns include a cooking oil-filled arrest and a Machete Murderer connection....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

155 - You Don’t Know What You Don’t Know
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of Su Taraskiewicz and Abraham Shakespeare....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 104
This week’s hometowns include a food court stabbing and a Richard Speck connection....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

154 - DNA Dad
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Thelma Todd and the Footpath Murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 103
This week’s “New Year’s”-themed hometowns include family skeletons and solving a murder....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


153 - MFM: Origins
Karen and Georgia end 2018 with a selection of the origins of some of your favorite quotes....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 102
This week’s "Christmas-themed" hometowns include a killer in the home and riding in cars with strangers....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

152 - Live at the O2 Academy in Glasgow
Karen and Georgia cover the Burke & Hare murders and the Bible John murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 101
This week’s hometowns include mennonite murder and a city found in a wall....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 100
This week’s hometowns include a Mary Vincent connection and rehab cults....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


150 - How Dare You Kelli
Karen and Georgia cover the hanging of Alice Riley and the murder of Reyna Marroquín....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime 742429 KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 99
This week’s hometowns include ice cream trucks and some creepy uncle stories....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

149 - Lifestyle & Feelings
Karen and Georgia cover the Missoula Mauler and the Forest Park Killer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


The Exactly Right Podcast Network Spotlight Minisode
Karen and Georgia give you a sneak peek at the first four shows joining their new podcast network, Exactly Right. Listen to the new shows right now:DYNARThe PurrrcastThe Fall LineThis Podcast Will Kill You...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 98
This week’s hometowns include a ship-based murder and a Whitey Bulger connection....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

148 - Live at the Community Center Theater in Sacramento
Karen and Georgia cover attempted assassin Squeaky Fromme and the Lodi Haystack Murder. Plus surprise guest Paul Holes....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 97
This week’s hometowns include a ‘murder meet cute’ and a cult lawyer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

147 - Live in Austin
Karen and Georgia cover Robert Elmer Kleason and the murder of Steven Robards....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 96
This week’s hometowns include a clown attack and advice from a mobster....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


146 - Dawna’s Skinny Lighter
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Randy Mock and the Seattle Cyanide Poisonings....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 95
This week’s hometowns from Atlanta and Austin include a pastor story and the Lemur Man....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

145 - Live at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles
Karen and Georgia cover the satanic panic of McMartin Pre-School and the Mannequin at the Carnival....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 94
This week’s Halloween-themed hometowns include ghost stories and oozing walls....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 93
This week’s hometowns from the Bay Area include a freeway mystery and a Zodiac Killer connection....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff


143 - DeSabotage
Karen and Georgia cover the truth behind poisoned Halloween candy and the murder of Carol Stuart....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 92
This week’s hometowns from the Pacific Northwest include a flip phone ghost story and a death bed confession....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy Truecrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 91
This week’s hometowns include a creepy ghost story and bank robbery coincidences....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

141 - Big Thirsty Robe
Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Heidi and Christine and the murder of Linda Bailey Brown....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 90
This week’s hometowns from New York City include a hand found in a canal and an attempted burglary....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


140 - Icebreakers & More!
Karen and Georgia answer your questions....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 89
This week’s hometowns from North and South Carolina include a John List connection and a trivia night story....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

139 - A Hundred Feelings
Karen and Georgia cover the Kunz Family Murders and the murder of Joan Dawley....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 88
This week’s hometowns include going to jury duty on acid and a car accident mystery....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 87
This week’s hometowns include an arms dealer and drug drops....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


137 - Gloogle
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of BBC reporter Jill Dando and the Andrews’ Family ‘Hauntings.’...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 86
This week’s hometowns include attempted kidnappings and things found in cars....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

136 - The Uninhibited
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Stanford White and the case of the Boys on the Tracks....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 85
This week’s hometowns include an attempted murder and swinging grandparents....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

135 - The Multiverse Trajectory
Karen and Georgia cover the Party Monster murder of Angel Melendez and the story of Clarence and Melinda Elkins....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 84
This week’s hometown episode features stories of people hiding secret lives. Brought to you by @SearchingMovie....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 83
This week’s hometowns include a cult member roommate and a surprise found in a wall....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

133 - Made of Crystals
Karen and Georgia cover the Gainesville Ripper and the Lady of the Dunes....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 82
This week’s hometowns include true love at the morgue and a rigor mortis story....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

132 - Awful Peanut
Karen and Georgia cover the cult of Synanon and the death of Azaria Chamberlain....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 81
This week’s hometowns include a bad piano teacher and a cemetery surprise....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


131 - Live at the Chinateatern in Stockholm
Karen and Georgia cover Nikita Bergenström and Sture Bergwall aka Thomas Quick....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 80
This week’s hometowns include a case of misplaced ashes and genetic testing gone wrong....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

130 - Mike Is Right
Karen and Georgia cover the Fall of the Romanovs and Fred and Rosemary West....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 79
This week’s hometowns include a Son of Sam connection and a golf-club wielding nana....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

129 - Coincidence Island
Karen and Georgia cover the Honolulu Strangler and the Galapagos Affair....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 78
This week’s hometowns include a dead body in a hot tub and a pair thieves....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


128 - Live at Albert Hall in Manchester
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Mary Ann Britland and Trevor Hardy....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 77
This week’s hometowns include a neighborhood intruder and a sinkhole/cult combo....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

127 - Our Beautiful Rat King
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Angela Samota and Finland’s Lake Bodom murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 76
This week’s hometowns include a home invasion and a bomb squad investigation....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

126 - Nice Office
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Lawrence DeLisle and the murder of Kim Wall....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 75
This week’s hometowns include cult stories and sword-based crime....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


125 - Bedside Astrologer!
Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Scott Johnston and Sean Farmer and the Glamour Girl Slayer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 74
This week’s hometowns include a workplace murderer and a serial killer Grand Am....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

124 - Errant Duct Tape
Karen and Georgia cover the unsolved crimes of Mr. Cruel and the murder of Girly Chew Hossencofft....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 73
This week’s hometowns include a cocaine story and a great-great-grandma’s deathbed confession....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

123 - Live at Vicar Street in Dublin
Karen and Georgia cover the Stoneybatter Strangler and Colin Whelan....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 72
This week’s hometowns include Golden State Killer connections and a druid murder....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes
This week, crime journalist Billy Jensen joins Georgia and Karen for a Golden State Killer case update AND THEN PAUL HOLES SHOWS UP!!!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered COMEDY TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 71
This week’s hometowns include a tiger sanctuary cult and some rabies tales....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered COMEDY TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

121 - Clomp Everywhere
Karen and Georgia answer listener questions in this special Q&A episode....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered COMEDY TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 70
This week’s hometowns include a Swedish bank robbery and a hiking discovery....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered COMEDY TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

120 - Live at the Orpheum in Los Angeles
Karen and Georgia cover LA crime journalist Agness Underwood and the Los Feliz Murder Mansion....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered COMEDY TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 69
This week’s hometowns include the Hot Dog Murders and a short ghost story....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered COMEDY TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


119 - Fingers Everywhere
Karen and Georgia cover the Lipstick Killer and the Lindbergh Baby kidnapping....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered COMEDY TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 68
This week’s hometowns include a JFK connection and a false confession....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

118 - Golden State Killer Caught!
Karen and Georgia cover the arrest of the Golden State Killer. Plus investigative journalist Billy Jensen calls in....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 67
This week’s hometowns include a knife fight at a wedding and a house filled with traysure....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

117 - Reality's Canceled
Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Teka Adams and the West Mesa Bone Collector....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 66
This week’s hometowns include a Drew Peterson connection and a parking lot discovery....

staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime GeorgiaHardstark Murder KarenKilgariff


116 - Robot Grandma
Karen and Georgia cover killers Jesse Pomeroy and Issei Sagawa....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 65
This week’s hometowns include a Hillside Stranglers connection and a jury coincidence....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

115 - I’ll Be Gone In The Dark at Skylight Books
Karen and Georgia join comedian Patton Oswalt, lead researcher Paul Haynes, and investigative journalist Billy Jensen for a discussion of Michelle McNamara’s book, I’ll Be Gone In The Dark....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 64
This week’s hometowns include a pair of mysterious shoes in a basement and a fruitcake in the mail....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

114 - Civic Order
Karen and Georgia cover the Hillside Stranglers and the murder of Dana Bradley....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 63
This week’s hometowns include a creepy dentist and cash found under a tree....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


113 - Live at Kingsbury Hall in Salt Lake City
Karen and Georgia cover killer Ronnie Lee Gardner and the Salt Lake City Library hostage incident....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 62
This week's hometowns include a farmer’s diary and a Ted Kaczynski encounter....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

112 - Galore Galore!
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of Rachel Hoffman and Bonnie Lee Bakley....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 61
This week's hometowns include the funny man haunting and a ‘lighthearted’ near kidnapping....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

111 - Figure It Out Kevin
Karen and Georgia cover the Van Nuys Courthouse shooting and serial killer La Mataviejitas....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 60
This week's hometowns include sand dune sinkholes, suspicious thrift store finds, and a horrifying call-in story about babysitting....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


110 - Live at the Palace Theatre in Columbus
Karen and Georgia cover serial killer Donald Harvey and the mystery of the Circleville Letter Writer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 59
Karen and Georgia cover your hometown stories including a lake monster, a holy water haunting, a Ted Bundy connection, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

109 - Project Artichoke
Karen and Georgia cover the mystery of Nurse Cindy James and the McStay family murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 58
Karen and Georgia cover your hometown stories including a few Jodi Arias updates, a first responder tussle, a suspicious chemical spill, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

108 - King Of Police
Karen and Georgia cover killer Matthew Hoffman and the murder of Little Grégory....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 57
Karen and Georgia cover your hometown stories from Salt Lake City including a kidnapping, haunted ballerina dolls, a hiking date gone wrong, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 56
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a few sinkholes, a childhood sister rivalry, the most intense first day of work ever, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

106 - Courage Shoulders
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Theresa Katherine Foster and killer Luigi Longhi....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 55
Karen and Georgia cover your hometown stories from Cleveland and Columbus including two gas station close calls, making a mugger cry, a killer in the family, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

105 - Proclensity
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Christa Worthington and the case of Typhoid Mary....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 54
Karen and Georgia cover your hometown stories from New Orleans, Atlanta, and Nashville including a good dog, foot stompings, a haunted elevator, some Satanic Panic, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


104 - Garden Party
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Susan Kuhnhausen and the Order of the Solar Temple cult....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 53
Karen and Georgia cover your hometown stories from Las Vegas and Phoenix including a mysterious intruder, a dungeon room discovery, a quick thank you, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

103 - Live at the Balboa Theatre in San Diego
Karen and Georgia cover the Betty Broderick case and the Heaven’s Gate Cult....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 52
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including finding a dead body in the woods, a surprising break in a murder case, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

102 - Decompressions
Karen and Georgia cover the Beast of Jersey and the Cleveland Torso Killer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

101 - Live At The Majestic Theatre in Dallas
Karen and Georgia cover cult leader Terri Hoffman and the case of Sandra Bridewell....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 51
Karen and Georgia read your Christmas-themed hometown stories including a tale of caroling gone wrong, a ceramic Christmas tree, a grandmother’s conversation with the mob, and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

100 - The 100th Episode
Karen and Georgia celebrate their 100th episode with a surprise case....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 50
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including the dangers of sleeping naked, another badass grandma, a Civil War horror tale and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


99 - Shin Kick
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Jennifer Pan and the murder of Irene Garza....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 49
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories about finding stuff in walls!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

98 - Grasp It
Karen and Georgia cover serial killer Marcel Petiot and the murder of Peggy Hettrick....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 48
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from St. Louis and Kansas City including a killer uncle, a lucky ELO belt buckle, a ghost that likes horses, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

97 - The Hague
Karen and Georgia cover killers David Meirhofer and Randall Saito....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 47
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a very special Tampa encounter, a Cheshire Murders connection, a Nazi prince, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


96 - Live at the Hard Rock in Orlando
Karen and Georgia cover killers Aileen Wuornos and Judy Buenoano....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 46
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a cannibalistic aunt, a mysterious mini-disco ball, Twin Peaks in real life, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

95 - Gesus
In this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Amish Serial Killer and three mysterious disappearances. Plus a special surprise from Dallas....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 45
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a Tampa serial killer connection, a twelve-year-old first responder, a haunted castle, the Son Of Sam dog, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

94 - Go Get Your Thing
In this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Bloody Benders and the Moorhouse Murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 44
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from Houston and Dallas including Dean Corll connections, the Lawnmower Man, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


93 - Live at The Grove in Anaheim
In this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the killer Daniel Wozniak and Disneyland deaths....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 43
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from Florida including a fieldwork tale, a lawnmower man, road trip incidents, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

92 - The Halloween Special
This week, Karen and Georgia read your spooky ghost stories just in time for Halloween!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 42
Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from Minneapolis and Madison including a serial killer relation, a badminton murder, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

91 - Live at the Sony Centre in Toronto
In this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover killers Paul Bernando and Karla Homolka, and the murder of Lynne Harper....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 41
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from San Diego and Anaheim including a mother’s brush with almost attempted murder, a deadly magician, attempted kidnappings, and more. Plus an onstage proposal from the Balboa Theatre!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


90 - Peak Experience
On this week’s My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover the Amityville Horror murders and the killer Neville Heath....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 40
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from Detroit and Toronto including spooky happenings from a nurse, a fingerprint dust date night, a teen that worked with a serial killer, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

89 - The Finch
On this week’s My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover Dean Corll and the Silent Movie Theater Murder....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


88 - Live at the Comedy Theatre
This week’s My Favorite Murder comes to you live from the Comedy Theatre. On stage, Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Ivan Milat and The Brownout Strangler....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 39
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a high school detective story, another helpful granny, and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

87 - Hither And Yon
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover Jack Gilbert Graham and the Son Of Sam....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 38
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from Australia and New Zealand including a true crime family, an online video game demon killer, supernatural tales from down under, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

86 - Live at the Enmore Theatre
This week’s My Favorite Murder comes to you live from the Enmore Theatre where the ladies discuss the "Melbourne incident" and cover serial killer Auntie Thally and the Shark Arm case....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy MURDER staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

85 - Live at the Boulder Theater
This week’s My Favorite Murder comes to you live from the Boulder Theater. On stage, Karen and Georgia cover the killer John Agrue and Theodore Edward Coneys, the Spiderman of Denver....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


84 - Harvard 2
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover the case of Theresa Knorr and a selection of modern true crime tales....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

MFM Minisode 37
This week's minisode comes to you on episode day! Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including one good dog, a childhood neighbor disappearance, a manhunt along the American/Canadian border, one badass grandma, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder

83 - The MFM/Unqualified with Anna Faris Crossover Special Pt. 2
In part two of the My Favorite Murder/Unqualified crossover special, Anna covers the murder of Rebecca Schaeffer, Georgia covers serial killer Charlie Brandt, and they all give relationship advice to a call-in listener....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff Murder


MFM Minisode 36
This week's minisode comes to you on episode day! Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a letter from from a young listener, a surprise lion encounter, a touching ghost story, and the 'laziest' kidnapping attempt ever....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

82 - The MFM/Unqualified with Anna Faris Crossover Special Pt. 1
In part one of the My Favorite Murder/Unqualified crossover special, Karen covers the BTK Killer, Anna quizzes Karen and Georgia on relationship dealbreakers, and they all give advice to a call-in listener....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

81 - Weapon Bush
On this week’s My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover Peter Kürten, The Vampire of Düsseldorf, and the case of Jeffrey MacDonald....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


80 - Live At The Rams Head Live
This week’s My Favorite Murder comes to you live from the Rams Head Live. On stage, Karen and Georgia cover the killers Joe Palczynski and Joseph Kallinger....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 35
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a haunting or two, a friendship formed with a thief, a David Lee Roth impersonator, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

79 - Sharpest Needle In The Tack
On this week's My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover the Collar Bomb Heist and Jerry Brudos, the Shoe Fetish Slayer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 34
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a juggalo ritual, a gas station survival story, a death bed confession, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

78 - The Freshest Recording
On this week's My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of an Austin, Texas woman named Ellen and the case of the Oklahoma Girl Scout murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 33
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including a high speed chase, an FBI plane crash, an unforgettable sushi encounter, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


77 - Live At The Keswick Theatre
This week’s My Favorite Murder comes to you live from the Keswick. On stage, Karen and Georgia cover the killers Gary Heidnik and Edward Gingerich....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 32
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories including EMTS, London escapes, a follow-up to the Berkeley hostage crisis, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

76 - My Own Sinkhole
This week, Karen and Georgia discuss the murders of master forger Mark Hofmann and the case of the Central Park 5....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


75 - Breakfast Wine
On this week's My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia cover the Main Line Murders and the murder of Spider Sabich....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

74 - Jews Vs. Catholics
On this week's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Carbon Copy Murders and the Annecy Shootings....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 31
It's a new My Favorite Murder minisode where Karen and Georgia read stories sent in by listeners like you! This week's hometowns include: a story of survival, a light-hearted SWAT team takeover, an encounter with a creepy tree man, and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


73 - Chill Satanist
Hang in there, it’s a new My Favorite Murder! This week, Karen and Georgia delve into Berkley Hostage Crisis from 1990 and Fall River Cult Murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 30
On this week's My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown tales including the terrifying discovery in a crawlspace, the tragic murder of Micaela Costanzo, and the Smiley Face Bomber....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

72 - Steven It Out
This week, Karen and Georgia cover Larry Eyler aka The Highway Killer and The Pillow Pyro of southern California, John Orr....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


71 - Put It In A Door
This week, Karen and Georgia cover John Crutchley the Vampire Rapist, angel of death Genene Jones and the Netflix series The Keepers....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 29
In this week's MFM minisode, Karen and Georgia serenade you with your hometown stories including sad boys, a Santa Cruz killer, a murder marriage hotel, and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

70 - Live at the Moontower Comedy Festival
It's a new My Favorite Murder, live from Austin, Texas! Karen and Georgia cover the infamous Yogurt Shop Murders and America's 'first' serial killer, the Servant Girl Annihilator....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 28
It's minisode time! Do you know where your asses are? This week Karen and Georgia read your hometowns from DC, Baltimore, and Philly along with a hometown from Georgia's uncle Gene....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

69 - Never A Mannequin
Beef down, everyone! It's a brand new My Favorite Murder. This week, Karen and Georgia discuss the Riverside serial killer and the tragic mystery surrounding Keith Warren's death....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

68 - Q&T&A
On this week’s My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia answer your questions about humble beginnings, going back in time to be part of an investigation, finding their favorite murder, GPS whistles, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 27
On a special My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read stories from EMTs, first responders, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

67 - Live At The Egyptian Room
Live from Indianapolis' The Egyptian Room, it's an all new My Favorite Murder! This week, Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Belle Gunness and Herb Baumeister. Follow along with the visuals from this week's episode here by scrolling through the images as seen originally on stage @ https://instagram.com/p/BTrZwhol1uC/...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 26
Let's stop and start it for a new My Favorite Murder minisode where Karen and Georgia read your hometown murders. This week your stories involve a retirement community, a ball-peen hammer, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


66 - The Devil's Number
Come shoegaze with us on the latest My Favorite Murder! This week, Karen and Georgia go mostly to Europe to cover the exorcism of Anneliese Michel and the Vienna Strangler, Jack Unterweger....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 25
This week on a new My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories from Austin including an Arby's axe murder, a haunted apartment, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

65 - Pre-Milked Cereal
Get synced up for a brand new My Favorite Murder. This week, Karen and Georgia discuss the mysterious killing of Ronni Chasen and the tragic death of Mitrice Richardson....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


64 - Live At Revolution Hall
Live in Portland, it's a brand new My Favorite Murder! Recorded during a three-night stint at Revolution Hall, Karen and Georgia cover the terrible Bobby Jack Fowler and the mysterious Cline Falls Hatchet Attack....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 24
Get ready to go downtown for your My Favorite minisode hometowns! Karen and Georgia read your local tales this week based out of Indianapolis, Milwaukee, and Chicago....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

63 - Steven's Tuxedo
Quit your job, get a spiral notebook, and listen to this week's My Favorite Murder. Karen and Georgia cover the crimes of the demonic Joseph Edward Duncan III and the Coen Brothers-esque Fred Neulander....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 23
This ain't our first minisodeo, but it is a new My Favorite Murder mini where Karen and Georgia read your hometown stories! This week, we read hometown murders and near misses from Portland and the surrounding Oregon wilderness....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

62 - Trust Issues & Ice Skate Shoes
On this week's MFM, Karen and Georgia tell stories from the road and then segue into the infamous Moors murders and the lesser known Gorilla Killer....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

61 - Live at The Neptune
Live in Seattle, it's a new episode of My Favorite Murder. Karen and Georgia cover the murder of punk singer Mia Zapata and serial killer Ted Bundy....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 22
On this week's minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown murders including a cop's run in with Ottis Toole, pizza drug lords, and one about why you should never go to Poughkeepsie....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

60 - Jazz It
On this week's episode, Karen and Georgia explore the mysteries surrounding The Axeman of New Orleans and family annihilator William Bradford Bishop....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 21
From the shores of a lake at the bottom of the ocean, it's a My Favorite Murder minisode! This week Karen and Georgia read your hometown murders including a neighbor with cannibalistic intentions, the Wesson Massacre, and a near miss while peeing in the woods....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


59 - Live At The Wilbur
We're in the combat zone for a live episode of My Favorite Murder in Boston! Karen and Georgia cover the Molly Bish case and a serial killer who called himself The Giggler! Follow along with the visuals from this week's episode here by scrolling through the images as seen originally on stage: https://www.instagram.com/p/BRbOol7D5om/...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 20
We're not here to talk about microphones, we're here to talk about your hometown murders! On this week's My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia continue the tour theme and read your hometown murders from Boston and New York City....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

58 - Some Quiet Sunday
What a huge goddamn relief, it's a new My Favorite Murder! This week Karen and Georgia talk about the folie à deux of the Eriksson twins and the crimes of Mel Ignatow. Plus a hometown murder from comedian Kurt Braunohler....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


57 - Live At The Fox Theater
Live at the Fox Theater, Karen and Georgia kick off the My Favorite Murder Spring Tour (official title still pending). Onstage in Oakland, they talk about the Speed Freak Killers and the earthquake-fearing Herbert Mullin....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 19
Oakland, Vancouver, and Seattle: it's your hometown murders on this week's My Favorite Murder minisode! Karen and Georgia retell an 'I Survived'-esque story, read a pot-smoker's near brush with a killer, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

56- Service Poodle
There's no time to sing a goddamn song, but there is time for My Favorite Murder! This week Karen and Georgia unpack the Darlie Routier case and the true story behind Hollywood star Fatty Arbuckle....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 18
This week's My Favorite Murder minisode was found under the sink, next to a collection of creepy poems. Hear Karen and Georgia read your hometown murder stories including the Donald Duck Killer, the Meat Cleaver Murderer, and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

55 - Let's Hear Your Podcast
Full of twists and turns, it's a new My Favorite Murder! This week Karen and Georgia get real deep into the story of french maids, Christine and Léa Papin and the "carnival atmosphere" surrounding Dr. Sam Sheppard and the murder of his wife, Marilyn Reese Sheppard....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 17
Jazz hands up, it's a new My Favorite Murder minisode! Karen and Georgia read your hometown murders from all over the world including Austria, Ireland, El Paso Texas, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered comedy TrueCrime KarenKilgariff


54 - Valet Area
Let Karen and Georgia be your weekly valet to My Favorite Murder. On this episode they cover the terrible deeds of Nathaniel Bar-Jonah and Rodney Alcala....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

53 - Live at The Orpheum
Wake up dads, it's My Favorite Murder live from The Orpheum theater in Los Angeles! On stage, Karen and Georgia tell the sordid tales of the LA Ripper and the Greystone Mansion Murders. Then, Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds from The Dollop stop by to tell their 'hometown' stories....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 16
My Favorite Murder Minisodes turn 16! To celebrate, Karen and Georgia read two New Zealand hometown murders, the dirty secret behind Kip's Tacos, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


52 - Bonjour, Internet!
Always in fashion and never full price, it's My Favorite Murder! This week Karen and Georgia tackle internet murderer Luka Magnotta and the unsolved case that lead to the creation of the AMBER Alert....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 15
It's not fake, it's a My Favorite Murder minisode! Karen and Georgia recount hometown tales including Sonoma's Ramon Salcido, Mexican wrestler La Dama del Silencio, The Catman Of Greenock, and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

51 - A Bit of Oblivion
Ring those bells it's the latest My Favorite Murder. This week Karen and Georgia recount the harrowing survival story of Jennifer Holliday and the tragic case behind the creation of Megan's Law....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 14
Dial 1-800-KILL-KILL-KILL it's a My Favorite Murder minisode! This week, Karen and Georgia kick off 2017 with your hometown stories about nextdoor murderers, young 'Bonnie & Clyde' types, twisted morticians, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

50 - The Golden Anniversary Episode
Rock, paper, scissors... it's My Favorite Murder! On this episode, Karen and Georgia delve into the mystery of the Somerton Man and discuss the 1984 bioterror attack by followers of the Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

49 - The Great Guy Law-Time New Years Spectacular
On this year-end legal extravaganza, Karen and Georgia talk to comedian and actual law school graduate Guy Branum about what makes murder murder. Plus more True Crime trading cards!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


48 - An Albert Fish Production
On this week's My Favorite Murder (now with a stick of shitty gum!), Karen and Georgia recount the Starved Rock State Park murders and the mysterious ongoing kidnapping case of Sherri Papini....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 13
On this week's My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read hometown stories from sister murderinos and give real estate advice on buying killer condos!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

47 - Live at The Bell House
On a live episode of My Favorite Murder in Brooklyn, Karen and Georgia tell the stories of New York's Torso Killer and the murder of Imette St. Guillen. Plus guest Jamie Lee shares the murder of Dee Dee Blanchard and the boys from Last Podcast On The Left tell their hometown murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


46 - Skippers Unite!
In a no nonsense episode of My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia discuss the serial killer Leslie Allen Williams and the enigmatic Israel Keyes....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 12
On this week’s selection of hometown murders, Karen and Georgia read a tale by a 13 year-old, share a listener’s Ted Bundy connection, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

45- Funky Diva
In a traumatic night of unbelievable circumstance, this week’s My Favorite Murder features the story of Lord Lucan and the mystery of the Summerhill Road Murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


44 - Live from the Chicago Podcast Festival
Karen and Georgia are live at the Chicago Podcast Festival talking about the Fort Worth Three kidnapping and Chicago’s very own John Wayne Gacy....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime FortWorthThree KarenKilgariff johnwaynegacy ChicagoPodcastFestival chicago

MFM Minisode 11
This week’s minisode features more hometown murders read to you by Karen and Georgia including tales of lust, drugs, murder, Iceland, and more!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

43 - In Arrears
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia talk with their mouths about a tragic murder/suicide at the International Dunes Hotel and the still-unsolved Chicago Tylenol poisonings....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


42 - Abject Failure
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia are here for you with a collection of hometown murders including the ever-evolving tale of Todd Kohlhepp and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

41 - Live from EW Popfest
This week was recorded live from the Entertainment Weekly Popfest 2016. Karen and Georgia share Hollywood tales of murder including Lana Turner's dark family secrets and the Wasp Woman, Susan Cabot. Plus a hometown murder picked right from the studio audience!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 10
In this civically responsible My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown murders including a family murder in New Mexico, a spooky sleepover tale, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


40 - Squad Gourds
My Favorite Murder is the perfect coffee table podcast for you. This week Karen and Georgia unpack the "My Way" killings in the Philippines and the terrible murder of Scott Amedure....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 9
On this week’s My Favorite Murder minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown murder stories including serial killer Henry Lee Lucas, murderer Mark Winger, and a two-parter involving a feigned love of camping, a dead body, and a couch covered in blood!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

39 - Kind of Loco
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia have their protective eyewear on to talk about Charles Albright, the Texas Eyeball Killer. Then they tackle the notorious and tall Co-ed Killer, Ed Kemper....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


38 - Sidebar Nation
It’s My Favorite Murder, this week with hand-holding and shit! Karen and Georgia share the story of the killer priest, Gerald Robinson, and prepare for their trip to Chicago with a breakdown of the 2016 Gage Park stabbings....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 8
Karen and Georgia read a selection of your hometown murder emails and dole out a small serving of true crime to get you through your week....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

37 - Liminal Space
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia discuss the murder of Peru's Ruth Thalia Sayas after her appearance on a game show, as well as the murderous reign of sweet little old lady Dorothea Puente in Sacramento, CA....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


36 - Live from LA Podcast Festival
This week, it's the first ever live My Favorite Murder broadcast from the LA Podcast Festival. Karen, Georgia and comedian/The Dollop co-host Dave Anthony talk about the Trailside Killer, the Wineville Chicken Coop Murders and Australian murderer Mark Erinn Rust....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 7
Hey! Didn’t see you there. It’s a My Favorite Murder minisode. This week Karen and Georgia read your hometown murders that include the spooky 'Bermuda Triangle Of Murder’ in the Wisconsin town of Kenosha, House Hunters: Quadruple Homicide Edition, a prep school Slender Man murder, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

35 - A Small Foreign Faction
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia reflect and ruminate on the circus surrounding the life and death of JonBenét Ramsey. Pop culture gone mad....

thecaseofjonbenetramsey GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime JonBenet KarenKilgariff


34 - Thirty Let The Bodies Hit The Four
It’s a Sciatica Special on this week’s My Favorite Murder. Karen and Georgia delve deep into the twisted life of Richard Speck and the equally terrifying mind of Martin Bryant with the Port Arthur Massacre....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 6
Yikes! It’s a My Favorite Murder minisode! Karen and Georgia read your hometown murder stories including the the Texarkana Moonlight Murders and the Sasebo Slashing....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

33 - What About Mimi?
This week, Karen and Georgia talk the increasingly surreal Jane Mixer case along with the Co-ed Killer and then recount the incredible survival of Jennifer Morey. Come have tea with us, Rosemary & Thyme style on My Favorite Murder....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode #5
You keep sending them, Karen and Georgia will keep reading them! This week’s hometown murder minisode includes a hexing witch beatdown, a shouting match with a serial killer, unfortunate back rubs, a recent unsolved river murder mystery, and more....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

32 - Just The 32 Of Us
This week on My Favorite Murder, Karen and Georgia talk the life and death of pop singer Selena and then give the lowdown on the Zankou Chicken Murders....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode #4
Karen and Georgia read your hometown murder stories that include a poisoned milkshake, a field full of wheat and blood, a ‘cliche reckless teenager,’ and a slumber party gone wrong. Does Elvis get a cookie this time? Tune in to find out!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


31 - Namaste Sexy
This week, Karen and Georgia dive deep into the world of Lululemon with the Yoga Store Murder and then tell the tale of Tent Girl and The Doe Network. Plus a hometown murder by comedian Guy Branum!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

MFM Minisode 3
In this special minisode, Karen and Georgia read your hometown murder stories that include a prophetic child, a heroic dog, the Easter Sunday Massacre, and more. They're all succinct and horrifying!...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

30 - The F*ck Word Murder Mystery Show
This week, Karen and Georgia discuss serial killer Cary Stayner and the Yosemite murders as well as con man/murderer Clark Rockefeller (aka Christian Gerhartsreiter aka Chris Crowe aka Chris Chichester.)...

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff


29 - Episode: Twenty-Nein
Karen and Georgia discuss family-annihilator John List, as well as Warriena Tagpuno Wright who fell 14 floors to her death. Plus a hometown murder by comedian Matt McCarthy....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

28 - I 28 His Liver With Some Fava Beans and A Nice Chianti
This week Karen and Georgia share stories that are new to the other: the Durham Family Murders and the amazing story of Terry Jo Duperrault....

GeorgiaHardstark staysexy murder staysexydon'tgetmurdered Comedy truecrime KarenKilgariff

27 - Your Hometown Murder Email Round-Up
In a very special episode, Karen & Georgia share just a few of the hundreds of listener hometown murders that have been sent to us....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


26 - Twenty Six Six Six
Karen and Georgia freak out over presents from listeners, then get dark with two child murders: Mary Bell and Lisa Steinberg....

comedy staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

25 - Twenty Knives
New favorite TV show talk followed by the Christopher Dorner killing spree and the tragic Cheshire Murders. Plus Georgia is bested by a hometown murder....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

24 - Episode ...And Twenty Justice Four All
This week K&G discuss Karen's tragic hometown murder, Polly Klaas, as well as the truth behind Kitty Genovese's stabbing. Plus must-watch documentaries and all the banter you can handle....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


23 - Making A Twenty-Thirderer
Karen & Georgia focus on their favorite survivor murder stories, featuring an escape from The Chessboard Killer, and the harrowing story of a pregnant woman fighting for her life. Plus a rad listener hometown murder and tons of banter. This episode is brought to you by Fullscreen! Get your free one-month trial today at fullscreen.com/murder!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

22 - The Girls with the Episode Twenty Two
This week Karen and Georgia give themselves the impossible task of making murders from the 1500s interesting. The Sawny Bean legend and the Princes in the Tower are the murders of choice, along with a listener hometown murder and a discussion of the new Simpsons documentary. Enjoy, Murderinos!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

21 - Because 7 8 9
This week the ladies go way off topic before launching into their favorite murders, which focuses on the Cleveland Elementary School shootings (aka "I don't like Mondays") and 1800s nurse/serial killer Jane Toppan. Please remember to stay sexy and don't get murdered!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


20 - 20/20
This week Karen & Georgia discuss the rape trial of Brock Turner before delving into The Night Stalker's victims and capture, and New Zealand's infamous Bain Family Murders. ​...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

19 - Nineteen Kills And Counting
This week Karen and Georgia focus on the depravity of the human race by discussing Norwegian sh*t head Anders Behring Breivik and the unsolved horror that is the "Freeway Phantom." Grab your anti-depressants and come along on a roller coaster ride of murder!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

18 - Investigateighteen Discovery
Karen and Georgia's favorite murders this week are creepazoids Lawrence Singleton and Franklin Delano Floyd, and boy, do they fucking suck. Plus lots of small (murder) talk and personal stories plus all the staying sexy and not getting murdered you've come to know and love. Enjoy, murderionos!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 2
In minisodes Karen & Georgia read the hometown murders that listeners email in (myfavoritemurder@gmail.com) and play recordings of hometown murders from friends. Loads of murderey fun!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

17 - Episode SE7ENteen
This week's favorite murders include the killing of 13 year old Jennifer Moore in Novato, CA, and the murder-suicide of pro-wrestler Chris Benoit and his family. Plus tons of personal stories, shit talking, staying sexy, and not getting murdered....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

16 - Blood Murder Sixteen Magik
The ladies discuss their new crime show obsession, The Family, along with the murder of Chandra Levy and the sad story of Sylvia Likens. Plus a hometown murder from comedian Kara Klenk....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


15 - Definitely Not Episode 16
The theme this week is "murders from the year 2000," with Harold Shipman and the Setagay Family Murders taking the stage....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

14 - You Sexy Motherfourteen
Karen and Georgia tackle their favorite 1990s murders, featuring serial killer Joseph Naso and the death of Sherrice Iverson in Nevada....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

13 - Thirteen Going On Murdy
This week Karen and Georgia tell each other their favorite murders from the 1980s, featuring The Preppie Murder and the Keddie Murders. Plus your favorite murders and lots of stabby talk!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


12 - Our Bodies, Our Twelves
Karen and Georgia get deep when they discuss the murder that started their obsession with true crime: a kid on fire and a mom that assassinated her children. Happy listening!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

11 - What the Helleven
The theme this week is "cannibals" and it gets gross when Karen discusses murder and mayhem on a Greyhound bus, and Georgia goes classic with everyone's favorite nasty old man, Albert Fish. Plus lots of shit talking and staying sexy, as always....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

10 - Murderous TENdencies
This week's topic is "weird murders," featuring Who Put Bella In the Witch Elm and Richard Chase (The Vampire of Sacramento). Plus murder books and personal stories galore!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


MFM Minisode 1
It's the first ever Murder Minisode! We read your hometown submissions and favorite murders on the topic of the week....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

9 - Color Me Nine
The theme for this episode is "hiding in plain sight." Karen covers an Exorcist serial killer and Georgia talks about children who murder. Plus stories and favorites from listeners!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

8 - Eight Is Enough Murders
This weeks topic is weird ways to die including cursed movies and the Coronado Mansion Death. Plus a ton of personal anecdotes from K&G and a hometown murder from Mr. Georia Hardstark, Vince Averill....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


7 - Seven Murders in Heaven
This week the girls discuss their favorite unsolved murders, including The Black Dahlia and Elisa Lam. Plus a hometown murder story by Doug Loves Movie cohost Karen Anderson and listener's favorite murders!...

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

6 - Stay Sixy
For their first themed episode, Karen and Georgia discuss children who kill their parents, featuring Alex & Derek King and Jasmine Richardson. The ladies also discuss TV shows The People vs. OJ and Autopsy, and read listener hometown murders....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

5 - Five Favorite Murders
In this episode we discuss LA Freeway Killers of the 70s, the Martha Moxley murder case and read more listener hometown murder stories....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


4 - Go Forth and Murder
The girls touch on Making A Murderer theories before delving into child killer Cropsey and the murder of Michele Wallace. Plus listener hometown stories including Adam Walsh, the girl in the box, and the Petaluma Tickler....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

3 - Our Favorite Thirder
In this episode, Georgia and Karen discuss the Cameron Todd Willingham arson case, the Oakland County child killings and comedian/We Watch Wrestling podcast co-host Tom Sibley shares his hometown upholstery murder story....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff

2 - My Second Best Murder
In this episode, Karen & Georgia discuss Paul Bernardo the Scarborough Rapist/Schoolgirl Killer, the assassination of Robert Kennedy and Alie Ward shares a hometown high school murder story....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff


1 - My Firstest Murder
My Firstest Murder - in the very first episode, Karen & Georgia discuss car accidents, Jon Benet Ramsey, and the Sacramento's East Area rapist. Plus a local crime story from Feral Audio founder, Dustin Martian....

staysexydon'tgetmurdered staysexy GeorgiaHardstark comedy truecrime murder KarenKilgariff